A coastal climate such as Tampa-St. Pete has many benefits, including sunshine, salty air and breathtaking views. If you live near water, the choice of roofing material is not just a matter of style. It’s also a matter for survival. Tile and shingle roofs are the two most popular options, but their performance is very different when they’re exposed to heat, humidity and high winds.
We’ll compare the pros, costs, and benefits of tile vs. shingle roofs to help you decide which is best for your coastal house.
Durability in Coastal Conditions
Asphalt Shingles
Shingles have a reputation for being affordable and easy to install. In a coastal climate they may not last as long. Their lifespan can be shortened by heavy rains, strong winds and constant humidity in the air. In areas with frequent hurricanes or salt spray, even the best shingles can only last for 15-25 years.
Tile Roofs
Clay or concrete tiles will last longer, particularly in areas with high winds and salt. Tile roofs installed properly can last up to 50 years. Natural resistance to rot, insects, and corrosion. They also tend to be more durable during storms, with many roofs rated for winds of up to 150mph.
Verdict: Tile is the best choice for those who prioritize durability and storm resistance.
Maintenance Needs
Shingle Roofs
If you damage a shingle, it’s usually easy to replace. You’ll need to do small repairs more often because they will degrade quicker in the sun, wind and air that is salty. Granule loss or curling is a common problem.
Tile Roofs
When something goes wrong with a tile roof, the cost of repair can be higher. Under foot traffic, or due to falling debris, tiles can crack. Repairs often require replacing several tiles or resetting the surrounding ones in order to maintain the roof seal.
Verdict: While shingles are less expensive and easier to repair, they require more attention. Over time, tile is less maintenance–but more expensive to repair.
Aesthetic Appeal
Shingle Roofs
Asphalt shingles are available in many colors and styles. Some even mimic wood or slate. They look great on many different home styles. They tend to fade more quickly in coastal sunlight and look flatter.
Tile Roofs
Tiles have a classic and upscale look that complements Mediterranean, Spanish or coastal style homes. The rich colors and curved shapes–terracotta, sand or even charcoal–offer an elegant look that compliments waterfront views and lush landscaping.
Verdict: Tiles are the best choice for curb appeal and long-term beauty, especially when used in Florida architecture.
Cost Breakdown
Shingle Roofs
- Material Cost: 90-120 dollars per 100 square feet
- Installation is faster and more affordable
- Total Cost: $5,001-$10,000 for standard-size roofing
Shingles offer a cost-effective solution for homeowners in need of a quick fix, or who plan to sell their home within the next decade.
Tile Roofs
- Material Cost: $300 to $600 per square
- Installation: Labor-intensive; requires specialized skills
- Total Cost: $15,000. $30,000.
The tile will last for many years, requiring fewer replacements.
What is the best roof for you?
Tile is a good investment if you plan to live in your house for a long time and need a roof with low maintenance, durability, and curb appeal. If your budget is limited or you’re planning to move within the next 10 years, shingles might be a better option.
Both materials will work in the Tampa and St. The right installation and maintenance is key to a successful coastal climate in Tampa-St. Your priorities will determine the best option: your budget, your style preferences, and how much upkeep you are willing to do.
This post was written by a professional at Baypoint Roofing. Baypoint Roofing is a State-certified, insured, bonded, and licensed roofing contractor specializing in insurance restoration, storm damage repair, and expert roof inspections and installations. With over 25 years of experience, we proudly serve the entire state of Florida. Whether you need a complete roof replacement or precise repairs, our skilled team delivers unmatched quality and service. Trust Baypoint Roofing, roofers in wesley chapel fl, to protect your home or business with solutions that endure the Florida elements and exceed your expectations. Your satisfaction is our top priority.